Local search is the one vertical where your website is not the main asset. For most commercial queries the Map Pack sits above every organic result, and what ranks in it is your Google Business Profile, not your home page. A business can rank third organically and still get no calls.
Distance makes it relative, too. There is no single position to report: you rank differently from one postcode to the next, and an agency showing you one number is showing you the one measured nearest your office.