SHORTLISTS · UPDATED QUARTERLY

Agency shortlists we publish, bias included.

Three researched comparisons of the agencies you are probably weighing us against. Every agency was checked on its own website, published pricing appears only where the agency publishes it, and there are no ratings, no scores and no rank order. RankedTag is on all three lists, positioned where it honestly belongs.

The rules these lists are written under

Most "best agency" pages are published by an agency that ranks itself first, and the pricing in them is copied from directories that stopped being accurate two years ago. We publish these anyway, under rules strict enough that the pages are useful even to someone who will never hire us.

Every agency is real and was checked at source. Not one entry was taken from another roundup. Nothing is invented: no agency, no client, no result, no price, no rating. Where a detail could not be verified on the agency's own website, it was left out rather than guessed at.

Pricing appears only where the agency publishes it. Across the three lists, eleven of the thirty-three entries do. The rest say "Not published", because a wrong number on a comparison page is worse than a blank one, and directory pricing goes stale faster than anything else on the internet.

No ratings, no scores, no rank order. We have not been a client of any agency on these lists, so any score would be fabricated. That includes schema markup: you will find no aggregateRating or Review on these pages, which is a thing worth checking on every other list you read. The lists are alphabetical.

The bias is stated above the table, not in a footnote. RankedTag publishes these lists and is on them. Each of our own entries names what we are not suited to, and on two of the three it says plainly that we have no case study in that vertical. If a list that includes its publisher does not tell you where the publisher is weak, it is an advertisement wearing a comparison's clothes.

They are refreshed quarterly, and each page carries the date it was last reviewed, both visibly and in its schema. If you find something that no longer matches an agency's own site, tell us and it gets corrected.

How to read an agency list that is not this one

Most of what follows applies to every comparison page you will read, including ours. The format is cheap to produce and expensive to produce honestly, which is why so much of it is decoration.

Check who publishes it. A large share of the highest-ranking agency lists are written by agencies that appear near the top of them. That is not automatically disqualifying, and it is what we do here, but it should be stated on the page rather than discovered in a footer. If the publisher is not named, assume one of the entries owns it.

Check whether the prices are sourced. Pricing is the single most copied and least verified detail in this genre. Figures circulate between lists for years after they stop being accurate, because nobody re-reads the agency’s own site. If a list shows a price for every entry, be suspicious rather than impressed: when we read 33 agency websites across three verticals, only nine published anything at all.

Check for ratings nobody could have produced. Scores out of ten, star ratings and rank orders imply the publisher has worked with every agency listed. Almost none have. A list that cannot explain how its scores were derived has invented them, and the same applies to aggregateRating markup, which is worth checking in the page source.

Check whether anyone is criticised. A genuinely useful comparison says who each agency does not suit, including the publisher. A list where every entry is excellent at everything has told you nothing, because the only decision it helps you make is to call whoever is at the top.

Check the date, and whether it means anything. A year in the title is trivial to update. A stated review date with a description of what was actually re-checked is harder to fake and more useful. Ours says which date each agency’s website was read.

What we learned reading 33 agency websites

The most useful by-product of building these lists was not the lists. It was discovering how few agencies publish anything about cost, and how widely the ones that do differ.

Nine of 33 published a figure. Among those, the monthly entry points spread roughly twelvefold, for work described in broadly similar language. Two firms broke the monthly retainer pattern entirely: one publishes a six-figure annual floor, another charges a percentage of revenue or funding. We have written that up properly, with each figure attributed, on the SEO pricing page.

The practical conclusion for a buyer is that comparing agencies on price is mostly not available to you, and attempting it with figures lifted from directories will mislead you. Comparing on scope is available: for this money, how many hours of whose time, producing what artefacts, measured how. Two proposals that look identical on price routinely differ by a factor of two on that question.

Looking for a partner rather than a shortlist?

These pages are for the stage where you are still deciding who to talk to. If you already know what you need, the argument for working with us is on the B2B SaaS page, the ecommerce page and the local page, and the craft behind all three is documented under what we do.